Jobshop with 6 Operators

Summary

OptalCPCP OptimizerDifference
Mean Objective5958.198347115957.79338843−0.404958677686−0.007%
Mean lower bound5955.318181825491.54958678−463.768595041−7.787%
Mean Duration34.83s63.26s+28.42s+81.604%
Mean solution time20.98s22.28s+1.30s+6.217%
Mean LB time1.16s1.46s+305ms+26.327%
# Optimal solution232220-12−5.172%
# Solution1022+12+120.000%
# Infeasible0000%
# No solution0000%
Mean # Solutions34.3422.56−11.79−34.316%
Mean # LNS steps54.78k
Mean # LNS steps / second1.573k
Mean # Restarts37.79
Mean # Restarts / second1.085
Mean # Branches9.420M72.51M+63.09M+669.690%
Mean # Branches / second270.4k1.146M+875.8k+323.829%
Mean # Fails2.799M2.308M−491.9k−17.570%
Mean # Fails / second80.37k36.48k−43.89k−54.610%
Mean memory usage18.27MB24.80MB+6.54MB+35.791%

Objective values

−45.00−40.00−35.00−30.00−25.00−20.00−15.00−10.00−5.000.00Objective difference →

Relative objective values

−1.0%−0.9%−0.8%−0.7%−0.6%−0.5%−0.4%−0.3%−0.2%−0.1%0.0%0.1%0.2%Relative objective difference →

Total duration

−300.00−200.00−100.000.00100.00200.00300.00400.00500.00Duration difference →

Relative duration

0%5000%10000%15000%20000%25000%30000%35000%40000%Relative duration difference →

Detailed comparison

Model nameObjective diffSolution time diffTime diffLower bound diffStatus OptalCPStatus CP OptimizerObjective OptalCPObjective CP OptimizerLower bound OptalCPLower bound CP OptimizerSolution time OptalCPSolution time CP OptimizerDuration OptalCPDuration CP Optimizer
jobshop-operators_abz7-6opers+1.29ms+34.4msOptimumOptimum122812281228122888.7ms90.0ms116ms150ms
jobshop-operators_abz8-6opers+24.1ms+46.2msOptimumOptimum126512651265126595.9ms120ms124ms170ms
jobshop-operators_abz9-6opers+57.9ms+83.7msOptimumOptimum124112411241124162.1ms120ms96.3ms180ms
jobshop-operators_abz5-6opers+8.26s+13.72sOptimumOptimum1299129912991299795ms9.05s998ms14.72s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_15_10-6opers+21.61s+21.62sOptimumOptimum48784878487848781.18s22.79s1.18s22.80s
jobshop-operators_abz6-6opers+3.51s+3.51sOptimumOptimum9919919919915.02s8.53s5.02s8.53s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_15_1-6opers+72.70s+72.70sOptimumOptimum49664966496649669.82s82.52s9.82s82.52s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_15_5-6opers+34.17s+34.17sOptimumOptimum518151815181518133.03s67.20s33.03s67.20s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_20_2-6opers+900ms+927msOptimumOptimum64466446644664461.03s1.93s1.03s1.96s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_20_3-6opers+25.96s+25.96sOptimumOptimum66536653665366534.28s30.24s4.28s30.24s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_20_4-6opers+4.53s+4.56sOptimumOptimum68876887688768872.37s6.90s2.37s6.93s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_20_6-6opers+87.78s+87.79sOptimumOptimum69816981698169812.52s90.30s2.52s90.31s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_20_9-6opers−339ms−321msOptimumOptimum6428642864286428509ms170ms511ms190ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_15_10-6opers−1.37s−1.33sOptimumOptimum77077707770777073.26s1.89s3.26s1.93s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_15_2-6opers+3.08s+3.11sOptimumOptimum74277427742774272.94s6.02s2.95s6.06s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_15_5-6opers+10.58s+10.60sOptimumOptimum76967696769676969.99s20.57s9.99s20.59s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_15_6-6opers+5.26s+5.28sOptimumOptimum737073707370737017.75s23.01s17.75s23.03s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_15_9-6opers+6.46s+6.48sOptimumOptimum75477547754775472.16s8.62s2.16s8.64s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_20_3-6opers−1.16s−1.11sOptimumOptimum987798779877987714.68s13.52s14.69s13.58s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_20_4-6opers−12.0s−12.0sOptimumOptimum982498249824982413.85s1.81s13.86s1.87s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_15_8-6opers−113s−113sOptimumOptimum5004500450045004114.68s2.12s114.68s2.13s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_20_15_7-6opers+45.19s+476.08s−3OptimumSolution5207520752075204798ms45.99s123.93s600.01s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_20_7-6opers+33.38s+33.43sOptimumOptimum98109810981098105.95s39.33s5.96s39.39s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_20_9-6opers−8.08s−8.02sOptimumOptimum1036510365103651036514.22s6.14s14.23s6.21s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_30_20_6-6opers−23.7s−23.7sOptimumOptimum956295629562956233.10s9.41s33.11s9.45s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_15_6-6opers+7.27s+7.33sOptimumOptimum97519751975197519.82s17.09s9.83s17.16s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_15_4-6opers+31.08s+31.12sOptimumOptimum1006110061100611006113.55s44.63s13.55s44.67s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_15_7-6opers+41.96s+42.00sOptimumOptimum96859685968596858.52s50.48s8.52s50.52s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_15_8-6opers+4.58s+4.61sOptimumOptimum100761007610076100767.12s11.70s7.12s11.73s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_20_5-6opers−4.06s−4.07sOptimumOptimum132161321613216132168.85s4.79s8.86s4.79s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_20_6-6opers−3.49s−3.39sOptimumOptimum134571345713457134577.48s3.99s7.48s4.09s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_20_8-6opers−361ms−346msOptimumOptimum133611336113361133616.96s6.60s6.97s6.62s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_20_9-6opers+4.89s+4.91sOptimumOptimum137851378513785137854.12s9.01s4.13s9.04s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_15_10-6opers−16.8s−16.8sOptimumOptimum1233412334123341233420.06s3.22s20.06s3.29s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_15_3-6opers+99.60s+99.66sOptimumOptimum1256312563125631256328.85s128.45s28.86s128.52s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_20_10-6opers−65.7s−65.6sOptimumOptimum1309113091130911309185.39s19.70s85.40s19.80s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_15_4-6opers+4.57s+4.63sOptimumOptimum1244512445124451244516.86s21.43s16.87s21.50s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_15_6-6opers−8.87s−8.79sOptimumOptimum1283312833128331283316.37s7.50s16.38s7.59s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_15_8-6opers−10.3s−10.2sOptimumOptimum1257812578125781257819.83s9.50s19.83s9.59s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_40_15_3-6opers+25.33s+25.37sOptimumOptimum9961996199619961145.86s171.19s145.86s171.23s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_20_4-6opers+5.48s+5.43sOptimumOptimum16617166171661716617781ms6.26s830ms6.26s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_20_1-6opers−16.7s−16.7sOptimumOptimum1668616686166861668626.48s9.77s26.49s9.80s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_20_9-6opers+5.43s+5.43sOptimumOptimum164041640416404164045.34s10.77s5.34s10.77s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_15_10-6opers−8.67s−8.64sOptimumOptimum499349934993499311.12s2.45s11.12s2.48s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_15_1-6opers+25.93s+25.93sOptimumOptimum5092509250925092711ms26.64s713ms26.64s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_15_4-6opers+696ms+704msOptimumOptimum4711471147114711814ms1.51s816ms1.52s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_15_5-6opers+30.67s+30.67sOptimumOptimum4961496149614961736ms31.41s738ms31.41s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_15_8-6opers+3.23s+3.22sOptimumOptimum5068506850685068604ms3.83s606ms3.83s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_20_4-6opers+1.07s+1.04sOptimumOptimum6539653965396539111ms1.18s152ms1.19s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_20_5-6opers−104ms−67.4msOptimumOptimum66496649664966492.92s2.82s2.93s2.86s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_20_6-6opers−159ms−131msOptimumOptimum69966996699669961.05s890ms1.05s920ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_20_7-6opers+828ms+839msOptimumOptimum6843684368436843282ms1.11s301ms1.14s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_20_20_8-6opers+281ms+296msOptimumOptimum6579657965796579389ms670ms394ms690ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_15_10-6opers+13.08s+13.13sOptimumOptimum76727672767276722.98s16.06s2.98s16.11s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_20_7-6opers−39.7s−39.7sOptimumOptimum1702617026170261702648.92s9.25s48.93s9.25s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_15_4-6opers+1.16s+1.14sOptimumOptimum7142714271427142152ms1.31s186ms1.33s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_15_5-6opers+629ms+666msOptimumOptimum75947594759475941.16s1.79s1.16s1.83s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_15_9-6opers−4.62s−4.60sOptimumOptimum75117511751175116.27s1.65s6.27s1.67s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_20_10-6opers+1.01s+1.04sOptimumOptimum10200102001020010200268ms1.28s296ms1.34s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_15_1-6opers−14.7s−14.6sOptimumOptimum723372337233723322.16s7.46s22.16s7.51s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_20_2-6opers−231ms−204msOptimumOptimum98729872987298727.10s6.87s7.10s6.90s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_20_8-6opers+1.94s+1.96sOptimumOptimum9848984898489848254ms2.19s286ms2.25s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_20_9-6opers−1.08s−1.05sOptimumOptimum100891008910089100891.57s490ms1.58s530ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_30_20_7-6opers−4.72s−4.67sOptimumOptimum99549954995499549.58s4.86s9.59s4.92s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_15_2-6opers+922ms+922msOptimumOptimum9272927292729272358ms1.28s398ms1.32s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_15_5-6opers−84.5ms+71.2msOptimumOptimum10052100521005210052384ms300ms419ms490ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_15_8-6opers−16.7s−16.6sOptimumOptimum1026910269102691026919.27s2.56s19.27s2.64s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_15_9-6opers−2.62s−2.55sOptimumOptimum104011040110401104013.53s910ms3.53s980ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_20_1-6opers−10.7s−10.7sOptimumOptimum1334013340133401334013.23s2.49s13.24s2.52s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_20_2-6opers+4.99s+4.99sOptimumOptimum132381323813238132382.89s7.88s2.89s7.88s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_15_10-6opers−13.0s−12.9sOptimumOptimum1020310203102031020370.14s57.18s70.15s57.25s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_20_6-6opers−8.95s−8.93sOptimumOptimum1302013020130201302014.49s5.54s14.50s5.57s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_cscmax_50_20_3-6opers+138.44s+138.45sOptimumOptimum16581165811658116581151.79s290.23s151.80s290.25s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_15_1-6opers+417ms+405msOptimumOptimum12137121371213712137473ms890ms505ms910ms
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_20_7-6opers−29.7s−29.6sOptimumOptimum1350913509135091350940.89s11.21s40.89s11.31s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_15_3-6opers+3.22s+3.28sOptimumOptimum132331323313233132332.88s6.10s2.88s6.16s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_15_4-6opers+2.03s+2.09sOptimumOptimum12357123571235712357428ms2.46s467ms2.56s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_15_5-6opers+57.6ms+143msOptimumOptimum128261282612826128268.18s8.24s8.19s8.33s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_20_2-6opers+617ms+560msOptimumOptimum16825168251682516825703ms1.32s760ms1.32s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_20_3-6opers+582ms+1.22sOptimumOptimum16528165281652816528698ms1.28s742ms1.96s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_20_6-6opers−52.3s−52.3sOptimumOptimum1671016710167101671060.64s8.29s60.64s8.35s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_20_7-6opers−2.43s−2.41sOptimumOptimum1688216882168821688213.05s10.62s13.06s10.65s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_20_9-6opers+4.36s+4.40sOptimumOptimum1701917019170191701912.58s16.94s12.58s16.98s
jobshop-operators_ft06-6opers+8.31ms−4.46msOptimumOptimum555555551.69ms10.0ms14.5ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_ft10-6opers+705ms+5.31sOptimumOptimum9469469469461.51s2.22s2.89s8.20s
jobshop-operators_ft20-6opers+135ms+134msOptimumOptimum1165116511651165125ms260ms126ms260ms
jobshop-operators_la01-6opers+7.00ms−13.1msOptimumOptimum6666666666663.00ms10.0ms23.1ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la02-6opers+192ms+190msOptimumOptimum65565565565537.9ms230ms40.1ms230ms
jobshop-operators_la03-6opers+14.7ms+9.35msOptimumOptimum59759759759725.3ms40.0ms30.6ms40.0ms
jobshop-operators_la04-6opers+27.0ms+54.2msOptimumOptimum59059059059033.0ms60.0ms35.8ms90.0ms
jobshop-operators_la05-6opers+8.84ms−9.15msOptimumOptimum5935935935931.16ms10.0ms19.2ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la06-6opers+8.76ms−9.26msOptimumOptimum9269269269261.24ms10.0ms19.3ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la07-6opers+22.9ms+15.4msOptimumOptimum8908908908907.09ms30.0ms14.6ms30.0ms
jobshop-operators_la08-6opers+14.3ms−15.4msOptimumOptimum8638638638635.73ms20.0ms35.4ms20.0ms
jobshop-operators_la09-6opers+8.20ms−13.0msOptimumOptimum9519519519511.80ms10.0ms23.0ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la10-6opers+8.22ms−13.0msOptimumOptimum9589589589581.78ms10.0ms23.0ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la11-6opers+7.46ms−14.8msOptimumOptimum12221222122212222.54ms10.0ms24.8ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la12-6opers+30.1ms+20.4msOptimumOptimum10391039103910399.92ms40.0ms19.6ms40.0ms
jobshop-operators_la13-6opers+21.8ms−4.73msOptimumOptimum11501150115011508.20ms30.0ms34.7ms30.0ms
jobshop-operators_la14-6opers+8.38ms−10.7msOptimumOptimum12921292129212921.62ms10.0ms20.7ms10.0ms
jobshop-operators_la15-6opers+21.1ms+29.8msOptimumOptimum120712071207120728.9ms50.0ms30.2ms60.0ms
jobshop-operators_la16-6opers+868ms+868msOptimumOptimum945945945945232ms1.10s252ms1.12s
jobshop-operators_la17-6opers−83.7ms−58.0msOptimumOptimum784784784784384ms300ms388ms330ms
jobshop-operators_la18-6opers+713ms+711msOptimumOptimum8658658658652.74s3.45s2.74s3.45s
jobshop-operators_la19-6opers+1.36s+11.44sOptimumOptimum9069069069061.14s2.50s1.47s12.91s
jobshop-operators_la20-6opers+1.05s+1.87sOptimumOptimum9159159159151.87s2.92s1.87s3.74s
jobshop-operators_la21-6opers−652ms−623msOptimumOptimum1333133313331333712ms60.0ms713ms90.0ms
jobshop-operators_la22-6opers+7.56ms+26.2msOptimumOptimum122112211221122122.4ms30.0ms23.8ms50.0ms
jobshop-operators_la23-6opers+120ms+119msOptimumOptimum1348134813481348200ms320ms201ms320ms
jobshop-operators_la24-6opers−202ms−193msOptimumOptimum1288128812881288262ms60.0ms263ms70.0ms
jobshop-operators_la25-6opers+51.3ms+49.9msOptimumOptimum1252125212521252149ms200ms150ms200ms
jobshop-operators_la26-6opers−20.2ms−12.6msOptimumOptimum1753175317531753100ms80.0ms103ms90.0ms
jobshop-operators_la27-6opers+409ms+428msOptimumOptimum1806180618061806231ms640ms232ms660ms
jobshop-operators_la28-6opers−51.9ms−54.5msOptimumOptimum1781178117811781102ms50.0ms105ms50.0ms
jobshop-operators_la29-6opers+165ms+164msOptimumOptimum1655165516551655435ms600ms436ms600ms
jobshop-operators_la30-6opers+79.2ms+77.6msOptimumOptimum17801780178017801.32s1.40s1.32s1.40s
jobshop-operators_la31-6opers−2.10s−2.08sOptimumOptimum25322532253225322.91s810ms2.92s840ms
jobshop-operators_la32-6opers+851ms+859msOptimumOptimum2762276227622762579ms1.43s581ms1.44s
jobshop-operators_la33-6opers−1.92s−1.92sOptimumOptimum24952495249524952.91s990ms2.91s990ms
jobshop-operators_la34-6opers+7.84s+7.84sOptimumOptimum25572557255725571.13s8.97s1.14s8.98s
jobshop-operators_la35-6opers−2.13s−2.13sOptimumOptimum25812581258125814.19s2.06s4.19s2.06s
jobshop-operators_la36-6opers+1.43s+1.43sOptimumOptimum1957195719571957253ms1.68s254ms1.68s
jobshop-operators_la37-6opers+523ms+521msOptimumOptimum20952095209520952.28s2.80s2.28s2.80s
jobshop-operators_la38-6opers−278ms−280msOptimumOptimum1870187018701870358ms80.0ms360ms80.0ms
jobshop-operators_la39-6opers+123ms+131msOptimumOptimum192619261926192687.1ms210ms88.7ms220ms
jobshop-operators_la40-6opers−554ms−546msOptimumOptimum19121912191219121.37s820ms1.38s830ms
jobshop-operators_orb01-6opers+4.49s+10.25sOptimumOptimum10711071107110712.20s6.69s4.54s14.79s
jobshop-operators_orb02-6opers+5.33s+7.56sOptimumOptimum9079079079072.10s7.43s4.07s11.63s
jobshop-operators_orb03-6opers+10.25s+23.65sOptimumOptimum10361036103610366.79s17.04s14.17s37.82s
jobshop-operators_orb04-6opers+5.17s+7.38sOptimumOptimum10271027102710272.23s7.40s3.15s10.53s
jobshop-operators_orb05-6opers+127ms+2.06sOptimumOptimum891891891891433ms560ms1.08s3.14s
jobshop-operators_orb06-6opers+3.43s+14.25sOptimumOptimum10361036103610365.93s9.36s16.08s30.33s
jobshop-operators_orb07-6opers+27.61s+23.36sOptimumOptimum4144144144143.51s31.12s8.42s31.78s
jobshop-operators_orb08-6opers+1.21s+1.26sOptimumOptimum899899899899232ms1.44s235ms1.49s
jobshop-operators_orb09-6opers+996ms+2.29sOptimumOptimum943943943943644ms1.64s836ms3.13s
jobshop-operators_orb10-6opers+14.94s+15.96sOptimumOptimum9799799799793.12s18.06s8.26s24.22s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_40_20_3-6opers−326s−325sOptimumOptimum14029140291402914029351.49s25.96s351.49s26.03s
jobshop-operators_demirkol_rcmax_50_15_2-6opers−310s−310sOptimumOptimum12660126601266012660370.23s60.62s370.24s60.71s
jobshop-operators_swv01-6opers−2SolutionSolution1686168416241624209.08s438.67s10min10min
jobshop-operators_swv02-6opers−8SolutionSolution1735172716671667425.90s413.95s10min10min
jobshop-operators_swv03-6opers+3SolutionSolution1706170916501650340.28s276.85s10min10min
jobshop-operators_swv06-6opers−1.41s−1.41sOptimumOptimum25402540254025401.95s540ms1.95s540ms
jobshop-operators_swv07-6opers−5.81s−5.82sOptimumOptimum24282428242824289.07s3.26s9.08s3.26s
jobshop-operators_swv08-6opers−284ms−276msOptimumOptimum26352635263526352.52s2.24s2.53s2.25s
jobshop-operators_swv09-6opers+2−3OptimumSolution250725092507250418.45s5.13s86.70s600.01s
jobshop-operators_swv10-6opers+7.80s+7.80sOptimumOptimum2623262326232623523ms8.32s526ms8.33s
jobshop-operators_swv04-6opers+1SolutionSolution1776177717071707373.32s123.46s10min10min
jobshop-operators_swv05-6opers+4SolutionSolution1733173716831683145.21s210.33s10min10min
jobshop-operators_swv11-6opers−19SolutionSolution4328430942344234191.59s85.52s10min600.02s
jobshop-operators_swv12-6opers−47SolutionSolution4349430242554255202.27s398.64s10min600.03s
jobshop-operators_swv13-6opers−2SolutionSolution4376437443104310504.40s297.92s10min600.03s
jobshop-operators_swv16-6opers+578ms+543msOptimumOptimum4223422342234223222ms800ms277ms820ms
jobshop-operators_swv17-6opers−2.21s−2.21sOptimumOptimum40774077407740772.53s320ms2.53s320ms
jobshop-operators_swv18-6opers+13.66s+13.69sOptimumOptimum41124112411241124.30s17.96s4.30s17.99s
jobshop-operators_swv19-6opers+739ms+747msOptimumOptimum42664266426642663.67s4.41s3.67s4.42s
jobshop-operators_swv20-6opers+5.52s+5.49sOptimumOptimum4103410341034103359ms5.88s415ms5.90s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta01-6opers+32.8ms+35.5msOptimumOptimum194619461946194637.2ms70.0ms54.5ms90.0ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta02-6opers+103ms+111msOptimumOptimum1893189318931893427ms530ms429ms540ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta03-6opers−173ms−175msOptimumOptimum1864186418641864303ms130ms305ms130ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta04-6opers+739ms+736msOptimumOptimum182518251825182591.1ms830ms93.8ms830ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta05-6opers+146ms+143msOptimumOptimum1876187618761876124ms270ms127ms270ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta06-6opers+626ms+624msOptimumOptimum1892189218921892204ms830ms206ms830ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta07-6opers−289ms−290msOptimumOptimum1926192619261926459ms170ms460ms170ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta08-6opers+76.3ms+83.7msOptimumOptimum1901190119011901124ms200ms126ms210ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta09-6opers−191ms−163msOptimumOptimum1973197319731973271ms80.0ms273ms110ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta10-6opers−177ms−180msOptimumOptimum1893189318931893257ms80.0ms260ms80.0ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta11-6opers+452ms+460msOptimumOptimum2408240824082408818ms1.27s820ms1.28s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta12-6opers−38.4ms+7.89msOptimumOptimum2594259425942594148ms110ms152ms160ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta13-6opers−289ms−261msOptimumOptimum2424242424242424639ms350ms641ms380ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta14-6opers+788ms+796msOptimumOptimum2385238523852385812ms1.60s814ms1.61s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta15-6opers+424ms+402msOptimumOptimum243224322432243286.1ms510ms118ms520ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta16-6opers−1.28s−1.27sOptimumOptimum25902590259025903.15s1.87s3.15s1.88s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta17-6opers−51.0ms−23.7msOptimumOptimum2591259125912591341ms290ms344ms320ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta18-6opers+104ms+58.0msOptimumOptimum248724872487248796.0ms200ms142ms200ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta19-6opers+63.7ms+54.2msOptimumOptimum246324632463246366.3ms130ms106ms160ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta20-6opers+154ms+137msOptimumOptimum252325232523252386.2ms240ms103ms240ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta21-6opers+80.6ms+68.1msOptimumOptimum3362336233623362129ms210ms142ms210ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta22-6opers+99.9ms+53.8msOptimumOptimum3358335833583358200ms300ms246ms300ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta23-6opers+985ms+993msOptimumOptimum3348334833483348585ms1.57s587ms1.58s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta24-6opers+8.03s+8.03sOptimumOptimum34003400340034005.22s13.25s5.23s13.26s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta25-6opers+734ms+714msOptimumOptimum3276327632763276266ms1.00s296ms1.01s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta26-6opers+84.3ms+108msOptimumOptimum343334333433343385.7ms170ms112ms220ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta27-6opers+610ms+582msOptimumOptimum3516351635163516120ms730ms148ms730ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta28-6opers−2.22s−2.21sOptimumOptimum33673367336733673.72s1.50s3.72s1.51s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta29-6opers+5.93s+5.94sOptimumOptimum34973497349734974.09s10.02s4.09s10.03s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta30-6opers−4.65s−4.64sOptimumOptimum33423342334233426.25s1.60s6.25s1.61s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta31-6opers−192ms−175msOptimumOptimum3767376737673767472ms280ms475ms300ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta32-6opers−2.84s−2.84sOptimumOptimum38683868386838683.55s710ms3.56s720ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta33-6opers−644ms−638msOptimumOptimum39493949394939491.19s550ms1.20s560ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta34-6opers−155ms−111msOptimumOptimum3908390839083908415ms260ms431ms320ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta35-6opers+2.96s+2.97sOptimumOptimum37393739373937391.09s4.05s1.09s4.06s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta36-6opers+60.4ms+108msOptimumOptimum3827382738273827130ms190ms162ms270ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta37-6opers−2.16s−2.15sOptimumOptimum39683968396839683.20s1.04s3.21s1.06s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta38-6opers+143ms+130msOptimumOptimum3721372137213721137ms280ms170ms300ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta39-6opers+33.5ms+30.2msOptimumOptimum3598359835983598157ms190ms190ms220ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta40-6opers+2.48s+2.46sOptimumOptimum3719371937193719277ms2.76s321ms2.78s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta41-6opers+222ms+229msOptimumOptimum5214521452145214238ms460ms271ms500ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta42-6opers+7.12s+7.13sOptimumOptimum5099509950995099234ms7.35s267ms7.40s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta43-6opers+141ms+275msOptimumOptimum4930493049304930199ms340ms225ms500ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta44-6opers+14.07s+14.06sOptimumOptimum5081508150815081201ms14.27s238ms14.30s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta45-6opers+581ms+575msOptimumOptimum5108510851085108229ms810ms265ms840ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta46-6opers+1.04s+1.05sOptimumOptimum5138513851385138252ms1.29s295ms1.34s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta47-6opers+236ms+409msOptimumOptimum5038503850385038194ms430ms221ms630ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta48-6opers−37.6ms−2.88msOptimumOptimum4996499649964996358ms320ms393ms390ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta49-6opers+309ms+298msOptimumOptimum4959495949594959311ms620ms342ms640ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta50-6opers−301ms−188msOptimumOptimum5110511051105110641ms340ms678ms490ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta51-6opers−1.79s−1.70sOptimumOptimum63206320632063204.00s2.21s4.00s2.30s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta52-6opers+281ms+303msOptimumOptimum6191619161916191399ms680ms427ms730ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta53-6opers−63.3ms+195msOptimumOptimum6231623162316231563ms500ms595ms790ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta54-6opers+173ms+405msOptimumOptimum6166616661666166337ms510ms365ms770ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta55-6opers−495ms−438msOptimumOptimum61456145614561453.58s3.09s3.59s3.15s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta56-6opers+26.8ms+287msOptimumOptimum6325632563256325483ms510ms513ms800ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta57-6opers+287ms+333msOptimumOptimum6406640664066406223ms510ms247ms580ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta58-6opers+850ms+900msOptimumOptimum6515651565156515470ms1.32s500ms1.40s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta59-6opers−7.62s−7.45sOptimumOptimum61446144614461448.25s630ms8.25s800ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta60-6opers+492ms+460msOptimumOptimum6300630063006300338ms830ms370ms830ms
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta61-6opers−14.4s−14.4sOptimumOptimum849484948494849421.95s7.58s21.96s7.58s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta62-6opers+264ms+937msOptimumOptimum86008600860086001.07s1.33s1.10s2.04s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta63-6opers+12.18s+12.14sOptimumOptimum81878187818781871.22s13.40s1.26s13.40s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta64-6opers+62.72s+62.68sOptimumOptimum80778077807780771.41s64.13s1.45s64.13s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta65-6opers+5.03s+5.00sOptimumOptimum8200820082008200700ms5.73s730ms5.73s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta66-6opers+579ms+563msOptimumOptimum8399839983998399581ms1.16s617ms1.18s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta67-6opers+678ms+642msOptimumOptimum82598259825982591.00s1.68s1.04s1.68s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta68-6opers+73.8ms+805msOptimumOptimum8318831883188318576ms650ms605ms1.41s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta69-6opers+788ms+1.26sOptimumOptimum8479847984798479652ms1.44s688ms1.95s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta70-6opers+454ms+1.02sOptimumOptimum8480848084808480506ms960ms537ms1.56s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta71-6opers+1.75s+597.96s−11352OptimumSolution16816168161681654642.01s3.76s2.05s600.01s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta72-6opers−90.2ms+598.26s−11047OptimumSolution16228162281622851811.71s1.62s1.75s600.01s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta73-6opers+758ms+598.24s−11203OptimumSolution16771167711677155681.72s2.48s1.76s10min
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta74-6opers+2.89s+597.38s−11336OptimumSolution16675166751667553392.59s5.48s2.62s10min
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta75-6opers−510ms+598.62s−11062OptimumSolution16454164541645453921.36s850ms1.40s600.02s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta76-6opers+2.37s+598.25s−11387OptimumSolution16729167291672953421.72s4.09s1.76s600.01s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta77-6opers+2.09s+597.92s−11517OptimumSolution16953169531695354362.04s4.13s2.08s10min
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta78-6opers+1.29s+597.40s−11123OptimumSolution16517165171651753942.59s3.88s2.62s600.02s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta79-6opers+1.78s+597.81s−11265OptimumSolution16623166231662353582.17s3.95s2.21s600.02s
jobshop-operators_taillard_ta80-6opers+2.04s+598.27s−10934OptimumSolution16117161171611751831.72s3.76s1.75s600.02s
jobshop-operators_yn1-6opers−1.47s−1.40sOptimumOptimum19601960196019601.62s150ms1.63s230ms
jobshop-operators_yn2-6opers−2.45s−2.44sOptimumOptimum19611961196119612.98s530ms2.98s540ms
jobshop-operators_yn3-6opers−776ms−779msOptimumOptimum1938193819381938946ms170ms949ms170ms
jobshop-operators_yn4-6opers+2.21s+2.22sOptimumOptimum2014201420142014776ms2.99s779ms3.00s
jobshop-operators_swv14-6opers−7SolutionSolution4238423141704170122.04s565.15s10min600.03s
jobshop-operators_swv15-6opers−23SolutionSolution4235421241654165363.29s489.95s10min600.01s

Number of branches

0.00M100.00M200.00M300.00M400.00M500.00M600.00M700.00MBranches difference →

Relative number of branches

0%200000%400000%600000%800000%1000000%1200000%1400000%1600000%Relative branches difference →

Number of branches per second

0.00M0.20M0.40M0.60M0.80M1.00M1.20M1.40M1.60M1.80M2.00M2.20M2.40M2.60M2.80M3.00MBranches/s difference →

Relative number of branches per second

0%2000%4000%6000%8000%10000%12000%14000%16000%18000%20000%Relative branches/s difference →